Thursday, Oct 23rd

Last updateFri, 17 Oct 2014 9am

You are here: Home Editor's Desk Making jobs is more than just changing street names

Making jobs is more than just changing street names

The SME push is not a new concept in development. Small and medium enterprises were instrumental in the rapid development of Hong Kong in the nineteen sixties and seventies. Today, Hong Kong is one of the world’s major financial centres and acts as conduit for a very significant slice of financing that either enters or leaves the upcoming markets in China.
SME development as a theme was later taken up in several South American countries where the determinant links between poverty and crime, ownership and growth, education and development, were analysed and published in several academic papers. From there, it was expounded further by the development agencies resorting under the UN umbrella, and became the policy of force for more than thirty years.
In Namibia, the benefits of grassroots SME development did not go unnoticed. But SME development, despite all the work that has gone into this field, is not a straightforward concept. Neither is it easy to develop clear-cut policies, nor to implement a coherent set of principles to suit all conditions. SME development is a nefarious theoretical terrain with as many policy proposals as there are researchers working on the topic.
The local experience has proven that it is rather difficult to formulate one-size-fits-all strategies. This week saw an impressive SME Expo in Windhoek with many hopefuls in attendance. Marking the event as a priority area in terms of policy and implementation, was the presence of former Anglo  high brass, Clem Sunter, at the official opening. Sunter is famous for his “high road low road” scenarios which he formulated in the early nineties after a career of almost thirty years in the upper echelons of one of the world’s biggest mining conglomerates.
From a policy perspective, not even the definitions to delimit the SME sphere, are clear. In Namibia, the focus was always on micro enterprises to align development expectations with a population that is still mostly rural, and that is growing at a much heftier pace, than the overall economy. The result was that the initial focus was on self-employment until it dawned upon policy makers that not every individual is a born entrepreneur. Then our policies shifted to entrepreneurial support to ensure that those with the ability, actually rise above their immediate limitations, and establish the companies that will grow rapidly, and provide meaningful employment contributions. At that point, roughly 16 years ago, there was much talk about tender procedures favouring SME enterprises but after so many failed toilet paper manufacturers that could not survive supplying the government, all that emerged were a small number of fat cats.
Expropriation of the system became the norm, and the millions the GIPF squandered ended up mostly in the pockets of a handful of individuals, with a stream of bankrupt companies in the wake. SME development was not a huge success, and employment kept going down.
The problem is that from a public perspective, many of the initiatives were simply cosmetic. Similar to changing street names, where the suburb and the residents remain exactly the same, regardless of the name that street goes by. Poor residents in a poor neighbourhood are still in the same position today as they were ten years ago. Changing the street’s name added a nice cosmetic flavour but it did not upgrade the area. I suppose if political collateral in the form of Xs on ballots are important, then the cosmetics become important especially if the voters are still on the lowest rungs of development.
We need to realise that the success of SME development will eventually be determined by a rather complex set of policies with the backing and effort of a rather impressive number of development agencies. I sense the current focus of SME development has shifted to employment, but in reality I do not see this happen. Micro enterprises are still micro enterprises, and they usually employ only the owner and one, may be two, immediate family members. They exist because of need and not because the owner has big dreams of one day becoming the next fat cat.
So where does one find workable solutions between the two extremes of a woman selling apples at the taxi rank, and a connected fellow who uses government money to start up an undertaking that closes its doors at the first sign of adversity. Both claim SME status and both basically provide employment, and/or benefits, only to those in the immediate circle.
I suspect we will be debating the SME concept for a long time still, before we get to a system that actually works.

Articles In This Category
Editors Desk
Monday this week, marking the beginning of the second semester, the Ministry of Finance released its mid-year review of the Macro-economic Framework,...
Editors Desk
“Among many of the systemic flaws of autocracy, degeneration at the top, epitomised by ever-weaker leaders, is progressive and incurable. The...
Editors Desk
Against the background of the somewhat conflicting economic opinions expressed during the past month by the Reserve Bank in South Africa and the Bank...
Editors Desk
The official launch last week of the Kavango Zambezi Transfrontier Conservation Area between Namibia, Botswana, Zimbabwe, Zambia and Angola is a fit...
Editors Desk
The headline hits one in the face. I could not help lifting it from an opinion article originating from Europe but analysing institutional capacity...
Editors Desk
A conference in Windhoek this week on the technical and functional aspect of water recycling, grabbed the attention of all those who realise that...
Editors Desk
Late last week Anglo American plc announced it has reached an agreement with the Oppenheimer family holding company, CHL (Central Holdings Limited),...
Editors Desk
In the past two weeks, three SADC countries, Botswana, South Africa and Namibia presented their national budgets to their respective parliaments. The...
Editors Desk
Scouting through a list of issues that demand editorial attention this week, I was pleasantly surprised to learn on Thursday that unemployment is now...
Editors Desk
Elsewhere in this edition is a submission by the Namibia Consumer Trust, a local lobby group for the protection of consumer rights and interests, on...
Related Articles
General News
The development of human resources and institutional capacity is key in addressing the multiple socio-economic challenges affecting Namibia and with...
General News
The unemployment rate will decline as more companies increase their workforce during 2012, the Namibian Business and Investment Climate (NamBic)...
Sport
After joining the National Enduro Race series only four years ago, Windhoek born Yana De Jesus, a self-taught racer and the second prize winner in...
General News
The City of Windhoek says it is on track to deliver 200 ervens in the Otjomuise Extension 4 area through a pilot public private partnership. Mayor...
Sport
The Economist recently caught up with the vibrant local cyclist, Windhoek born, Laban Naftal who recently came first in the Mariental Duathlon...
Latest Articles
Headlines
The winner of the Best Business Idea competition run by the Economist Businesswomen Club after their Businesswomen Conference in Ongwediva, was...
Headlines
The most discredited agricultural commodity, ostriches, are back on the farming radar after the Ministry of Trade and Industry, in collaboration with...
Editors Desk
Can one imagine how unmanageable the Namibian capital market would be if yields on government bonds came down by 11% on one day, only to jump up more...
17 October 2014 (35 hits)
Weather
What Happened? The layered atmospheric sandwich that started developing last week continued up to Wednesday this week at which point the last...
Headlines
The City of Windhoek commemorated World Food Day yesterday at Otjomuise. This is the first ever commemoration of the World Food Day in Windhoek and...